Friday, April 8, 2011

My Views On American Idol

American Idol never ceases to amaze me (and sometimes not in a good way either). I've been watching this show off and on since season 2. I missed a few seasons and then started to really watch it again during season 8 (when I became a huge Adam Lambert fan haha).  Here is what I have learned over the past seasons:

  • There is always going to be some kind of controversy. 
  • Fans will start "boycotting" the show after their favorite gets booted off. 
  • The right person never really wins. 
I've always thought that this show's voting system was messed up. Some say it's rigged. Could it be? Yeah, probably. But, what people have to realize is that the majority of people who are hardcore voters are teenage girls. Girls who like to vote for the hottest guy on the show (whether they can sing or not.)

Last night, a fan favorite, Pia, was voted off in a "shocking" results show. Personally, I really wasn't that shocked and here is why. Yeah, she can sing better than anyone else on that show, but she is kind of a bland performer. At least I thought so. I never really remembered her performances after the show. That and maybe she was "too good" to be on the show. When you pull of the singing she does, people tend to think "oh, she'll be okay. Someone will vote for her." And then nobody does. That's how she went home. People got lazy and thought she was safe.  Don't ever think your favorite is safe. That's always how they get sent home.

Now, fans are pitching a fit because they don't think it's fair. Maybe she did deserve to be there. I kind of thought Paul was going home (I don't see how he has made it this far..) or Stefano. I feel bad for that guy because you could see how he felt he should have went home. You could see the confusion and guilt on his face.

I see another guy winning this season. Personally, I see Scotty (the teenage country singer) winning the whole thing. I can't stand country music but the girls think he's cute and so they vote for him.  So, there is my prediction. If you're upset about your favorite not winning, let me say something. Most winners aren't very successful. The only two that really made it are Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. Adam Lambert didn't win and look at all of the success he is getting.

So, fans, stop taking the show so seriously. It's really more of a joke than anything else now with the change in judges. I'm disappointed in what they have brought to the table. According to them, everyone is "so good" when some of them aren't. We need someone to grow a pair and gain some of Simon's brutal honesty. Tell a contestant they suck when they do. The worst thing the judges have said to these guys is "you're a little pitchy."

Just my opinions haha. What do you think about this season of American Idol? Who do you think is going to win.

2 comments:

Chub Johnson said...

Very well put Melissa. I don't agree with about 50% of what you are saying, but we are all entitled to our opinions. Just FYI: Paul is sick. His voice is like nothing out right now. Just saying.

As far as the judge go....I also think that there is a difference between telling someone they weren't good and having to poop all over someone to make your point come across. I think many times Randy has been right on the mark with his comments. JLO called it last episode when she told Pia to watch how other greats perform. She said it for a reason. I just think there is no need for someone to sit there and be like, "that was simply horrific" a la Simon C. That's my take on it.

But, I truly agree with what you are saying about the voting system. The show is geared towards a younger audience. Most adults that watch the show will never vote. My wife and I voted the first time we were allowed to vote this season and haven't voted ever since. I've gone to the twitter accounts and Scotty's is definitely blowing up. But, I also don't want to take anything away from him because I think he is pretty dam good (I like country).

Either way, I still think the show is really entertaining this season, but I wouldn't mind a change in the voting system. Maybe just one vote per phone?

I foresee a Jacob, Scotty, Casey taking it this season.

Melissa said...

I respect your opinions, Chub haha. I see where you are coming from about Simon. Yeah, he could be downright cruel to some of the contestants, but I just feel like the judges right now are letting some of them off too easy. Of course this season is talented. They are all there for a reason.

I'm not saying Scotty isn't talented. He can definitely sing and his voice is amazing for a guy his age. Country just isn't my thing haha. I can also foresee Casey in the top two.. I think the reason why he almost got voted off that one time before the judges saved him was because voters felt he would be okay without their votes (like what probably happened to Pia).

It's definitely an interesting season to watch. With only two girls left... we'll see if they can last.

Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

 
Design by Free Wordpress Themes | Bloggerized by Lasantha - Premium Blogger Templates